How to Match Existing Stone Veneer

Whether you're expanding a feature wall, repairing a damaged section, or adding to your home's exterior, matching new manufactured stone veneer to existing veneer can be a challenge, but it’s far from impossible. With a little planning and a few insider tips, you can blend the old with the new for a seamless, professional look.

Identify the original stone product

The first step is to determine exactly what type of manufactured stone veneer was used in the original installation. If you worked with a contractor, reach out to them for the product name, manufacturer, and color blend. If the original veneer was a DIY project or the information is long gone, try these approaches:

1. Check for leftover boxes in the garage or storage area. Packaging often includes the product name, style, and color.

2. Photograph the stone in good lighting and take close-ups of individual stones as well as the overall wall pattern.

3. Reach out to local stone suppliers with your photos. Experienced staff can often identify the brand and style by sight.

4. Call the manufacturer directly if you suspect a brand, they may be able to help match it or offer alternatives.

Match by style and shape

Manufactured stone veneer comes in many profiles, ledgestone, fieldstone, limestone, stacked stone, and more. Start by narrowing down the style or shape that most closely resembles your existing veneer. Look for stone size and thickness, texture and surface finish, grout lines (tight-fit or wide joints?). Also, consistency in shape and installation style plays a big role in visual continuity.

Match the color blend

Color is often the hardest part to match. Even if you find the same style from the same manufacturer, the color blend may have changed slightly over time. Try these tips:

1. Order samples before committing to a full order. Compare them in natural daylight against the original installation.

2. Mix old and new stones throughout the new section if possible. This helps break up any slight color differences.

3. Custom tinting may be available. Some suppliers or masons can tone new veneer slightly to better match an aged look.

Pro tip: weathering changes everything. Original stone veneer may have faded or picked up subtle patinas over time, plan for this when evaluating new samples.

Blend the transition zone

The area where new stone meets the old is crucial. Here are a few tricks to minimize visual contrast:

1. Feather the new stone into the old by carefully staggering the joint, instead of creating a hard line.

2. Use a consistent mortar mix and joint technique so the installation looks uniform.

Consult a mason or stone specialist

When in doubt, involve a professional. Experienced masons have a keen eye for blending stone and often know which brands are interchangeable. A small investment in expert advice can make a huge difference in the final look.

Can you help me match my existing stone veneer?

We're happy to help you match your existing stone veneer as closely as possible! To ensure the best match, we kindly ask that you provide as much information as you can about the original product, such as the manufacturer, style name, and when it was installed, if known. Additionally, please send us 2-4 high-resolution photos of the existing stone veneer taken from different angles and in various lighting conditions. This helps us accurately assess the stone’s color blend, texture, and overall look so we can recommend the closest possible match.

Need to match stone veneer for a small repair?

If you're tackling a small stone veneer repair and need help matching new pieces to your existing installation, we're happy to assist! Please keep in mind that our website has minimum order requirements in place to help prevent damage during shipping. Because of these shipping constraints, we're unable to process orders below our minimums. If you only need a small quantity, we recommend checking with local stone suppliers, in many cases, the cost of shipping a small order from us would exceed the price of the stone itself.

Should I order samples?

Matching existing stone veneer can be quite challenging, even when you're working with the same style or manufacturer. Over time, stone veneer can weather, fade, or vary slightly between production batches, making it difficult to achieve a perfect match by photos alone. That's why we highly recommend ordering samples first. Seeing the stone in person and comparing it directly to your existing installation in the same lighting gives you the most accurate sense of how well it will blend. Sampling first helps avoid costly mistakes and ensures you're completely confident before placing a full order.

Can I use your samples for a small repair?

Our manufactured stone veneer samples are intended for color and texture reference only and are not designed for installation. These samples are often cut-down or individual pieces that may not reflect the full structural integrity, shape variations, or proper interlocking patterns of the full product line. They are also not packaged or tested for permanent adhesion, and installing them could result in poor performance or a mismatched finish. For best results, always use full-sized product from an actual order when doing any installation work.

How to match existing stone veneer

Matching new manufactured stone veneer to existing veneer is part science, part art. By taking the time to identify the original product, comparing samples carefully, and using strategic blending techniques, you can create a unified finish that looks intentional, not patched. Whether you’re adding on to a fireplace surround, extending an exterior wall, or repairing a section of veneer, the goal is the same: a seamless, natural look that enhances your space.

What's next?

Turn your vision into reality with our premium stone veneer! Shop now to find the perfect style or order a sample to experience the texture and color up close. Start your project today!

Have a question?

Please see our full terms of service.

For general information and questions please call: (864) 882-8960 Mon. - Fri. 8am - 5pm (EST) or email: info@mountainviewstone.net we are more than happy to help you.

Or you can submit your questions via our contact us page.

We look forward to working with you on your upcoming project.

The Black Bear Mountain Stone Team